Early in her community life, when asked how she would like to be remembered, she wrote, “as a caring, prayerful, dedicated woman of service.”

Sister Marguerite McGilly, SCSister Marguerite McGilly (Sister Regina Richard) was born May 29, 1937, in Manhattan, one of three daughters of Thomas and Mary Smyth McGilly. Marguerite attended Saint Mary School, Yonkers, Cathedral High School, Manhattan, and gained work experience before entering the Sisters of Charity of New York on September 8, 1958. Sister Regina Richard received a BA from the College of New Rochelle.

Sister Marguerite’s fifty-eight years of ministry began in childcare at Holy Name Day Nursery in Manhattan, and Saint Joseph Hall in Brooklyn. Her next thirty-six years of ministry were as a primary grade teacher in several schools. In the upper counties of New York State, she taught at Saint Francis of Assisi, Mount Kisco; Saint Mary, Wappingers Falls; Saint Mary of the Snow, Saugerties; and Resurrection, Rye. She also taught at Our Lady of the Angelus, Rego Park, and Saint Patrick, Manhattan. In addition, she served for several years on Staten Island at Blessed Sacrament,  Immaculate Conception, and Saint Peter schools.

In 2004, Sister Marguerite turned to a new area of ministry when she volunteered with Sister Mary Richard Rowley for eight years as a Pastoral Minister in Saint Sebastian Church, Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Sister Marguerite returned to New York in 2012 to join the retirement community at Mount Saint Vincent Convent, the Bronx, and later moved to Cabrini of Westchester, Dobbs Ferry. She died at the Hospital for Special Surgery in Manhattan on May 5, 2020.

Sister Marguerite treasured the experiences the weeks after 9/11 when she and Sister Mary Richard ministered to the heartbroken people of Staten Island who lost loved ones in the Twin Towers. For weeks, each day after school, they went to a shrine erected by the people near their convent home with a view of the World Trade Center site. There they listened to and consoled the people, brought food, and other needed supplies. They knew their presence gave strength and courage to those who mourned.

Early in her community life, when asked how she would like to be remembered, she wrote, “as a caring, prayerful, dedicated woman of service.” Sister Marguerite’s participation in the sacramental life of the Church, years of ministry involvement with children and families, the presence of family and friends for her, and the challenges presented as her health failed, truly portray her devoted spirit. Be at peace, Sister Marguerite, as you go home to the God you served so well as a Sister of Charity of New York for sixty-one years.


Date of Death
May 5, 2020


Prayer Service and Memorial Mass at a later date

Mary Gate of Heaven
Hawthorne, NY


Archdiocese of New York

  • Holy Name Nursery, Manhattan
    1962, Children’s Supervisor
  • New York Foundling, Manhattan
    1968, Chapel Duty
  • St. Francis of Assisi, Mt. Kisco
    1968–71, Teacher, Gr. 2
    1973–75, Teacher, Gr. 3
  • St. Mary, Wappingers Fall
    1971–72, Teacher, Gr. 4
  • Blessed Sacrament, Staten Island
    1972–73, Teacher, Gr. 2
  • St. Mary of the Snow, Saugerties
    1975–77, Teacher, Gr. 2
  • Resurrection, Rye
    1977–79, Teacher, Gr. 3
  • St. Patrick, Manhattan
    1984–89, Teacher, Gr. 4
  • St. Peter, Staten Island
    1989–93, Teacher, ES
  • Immaculate Conception, Staten Island
    1993–2004, Teacher, Gr. 3

Diocese of Brooklyn

  • St. Joseph Hall, Brooklyn
    1961–68, Supervisor, Child Care
  • Our Lady of the Angelus, Rego Park
    1977–79, Teacher, Gr. 3

Archdiocese of Miami

  • St. Sebastian Church, Ft. Lauderdale
    2004–12, Volunteer, Pastoral Minister